Verizon Dropping ISDN in Some States

ripCan the other major TelCo’s be far behind?

For so long, established studios have pooh-pooh’d early predictions of ISDN’s demise.  But now, the writing is on the wall.

I think it’s time to call the undertaker and buy the burial plot.

The argument has always gone that the studios — you know — STUDIOS – are refusing to give up their tried ‘n’ true solution for recording remote talent.  I get it. Change is upsetting.  But I can’t think of any studio (beyond maybe… Disney) with clout enough to forestall the major telephone companies from yanking ISDN support.

Read this announcement from the respected Radio World website.  (my thanks to “DemoDave” Martin of Las Vegas for this tip!)

The line disconnects mentioned in the article include the densely-populated New England states, especially the powerhouse NYC broadcast/entertainment market.  The article recommends not disconnecting any ISDN lines, as it might be hard to get them re-connected, and to order any new lines NOW.

I take no joy in this eventuality.  I worked hard to get my ISDN and even harder to pay for it.  BUT, I’m also seeking the next-best-thing, and if you’ve read this blog at all in the last year, you know I consider the top contenders to be Source-Connect, ConnectionOpen, and SoundStreak (no particular order), and the possibility of a new Skype service.  Those are all Internet-based solutions.  Frankly, I don’t see any other technology even remotely on the horizon to take ISDN’s place.

CourVO

The Search for ISDN’s Successor

connectionopen-aBroadband.

ISDN’s legacy technology will go away…eventually.

Lord knows how much longer the big TelCos will continue to support it.

Smart producers, voice actors, audio engineers, and others associated with the business of voice overs are searching RIGHT NOW for the next best thing.  It’s pretty well universally accepted that ANY succeeding technology for hi-quality remote recording will be internet-based.

I’ve been hammering this message lately…introducing and continuing to support ideas that seem promising.  It’s unknown if Skype will go that way, but it could.  SoundStreak holds promise.  SourceConnect seems to have the biggest jump on the competition, but I don’t see a lot of excitement over the product, now many years old.

The dark horse in the race, and a surprising contender is ConnectionOpen.  Like the other possible solutions, ConnectionOpen offers a means to record remotely over broadband.  Uniquely, ConnectionOpen holds and aggressively defends an innovative patent that underpins the service.

Better than me trying to explain it myself, I took the opportunity the other day to interview Lawrence Morrison, the developer and founder of ConnectionOpen.  Lawrence openly answers questions about his software, explains why his patent makes a difference, and details the possible application of ConnectionOpen for voice actors…all in this 12-minute interview.

I think you’ll find it worth the time.  Below, a brief mention of Morrison’s pricing structure.

ConnectionOpen from Dave Courvoisier on Vimeo.

Morrison adds the following points about pricing:

1.) Upfront cost is $0.
2.) Subscriptions will start at $25 per month. This will be a promotional price. It will go to $50 a month with a steep discount for a yearly subscription. We are still trying to figure out what that will be.
3.) At this point it is an all for one price deal. We do however plan to add more features, video, customizable interface, extremely secure remote storage and a personal newsletter service for self promotion.

Thanks, Larry!

CourVO

The Slow Death of ISDN

connectivityThe major telephone companies wish they’d never seen ISDN.

It’s a pain in the butt to provision, switch, maintain, uphold, and they’re not even sure why they do it.

The result is ever-increasing installation and monthly fees, especially in the fly-over states.

The evidence is everywhere and ever-increasing.

Two threads on VO Facebook groups this week were testament.

In one, Melanie Haynes stated:  ”…”Having my battle with them again…..Thought we’d settled it last year when I signed a 2 year contract with a lowered rate. Guess what? It will be only 1 year in Feb and my latest bill jumped the rate by $25..”

Others chimed in to say they’re paying more than $300/mo for their ISDN service.

Voice actor AJ McKay noted with frustration:  ”I’ve had mine for a little over a year. It went from 165 to 194 and now is $235. It really is ridiculous because they don’t train people anymore to service ISDN (according to the guy who just came to my house last month). I knew more jargon and about ISDN than he did.”

Still more voice-actors say they can’t even get an ISDN install in their town/city.  It’s not even available.

Much of this conversation was sparked by a blog my friend Bobbin Beam wrote on ISDN.  Bobbin just moved from San Diego, back to the Midwest, and is having a nightmare of a time getting her ISDN established again.  $50/mo in San Diego, now $214/mo in Milwaukee for a business account…personal accounts no longer available.  See:  The Unlevel Playing Field.

About this time, seasoned pros in NYC and LA will chime in and say “ISDN is never going away…the studios like it too much…you all are overreacting…too many people have preached its demise for too long, and it’s still here…” and more like that.  All of which bears some truth.

But the mounting evidence can no longer be ignored.  The owner of studio here in Las Vegas was lamenting how it’s getting harder and harder to find a decent long distance service for his ISDN connection.  If the studios are getting squeezed out of the market…there’s little hope ISDN will last.

It may be a couple of years, but now is the time to start looking.  There are several candidates:
(in order of likelihood)

1) Source-Connect 

From Source-Elements, Source-Connect already has pretty good name recognition and acceptance among studios and talent.  For some reason, it has never really taken-off…but with the slow demise of ISDN…maybe it can come forward and shine.  Configuration and set-up problems are well-known, though, and there remains occasional drop-out in the signal.

2) SoundStreak

Dan Caligor’s team is hot on the trail of a very sweet IP solution to remote recording.  It’s a service more than software, and now with it’s Windows Beta release and other big developments, Soundstreak has a real chance.  Read my recent blog about SS.

3) Skype

Yeah.  Skype.  After bouncing around under different corporations (Ebay?) Skype now falls under Microsoft’s umbrella.  Some lament this fact. I rejoice in it.  I think MS will make some hay out of this product.  Many a Podcast and Phone Patch are successfully completed using Skype… can top quality studio sound over this IP service be very far?

4)  Luci Live App

This $400 iOS app delivers the connectivity goods…but then you’re at the mercy of the inferior audio electronics of an iPad or iPhone.  It’s not terrible, but good enough for network promos?  I doubt it.

HONORABLE MENTION:  ConnectionOpen  This is a simple, easy-to-use interface designed for recording remote collaborative music sessions, but there’s  no reason why it wouldn’t work for VO sessions.  See my blog of Mar 2012 on this.

CourVO

Why The FBI Doesn’t Want You to Have ISDN

Personally, I figure I’m already in a file cabinet, or a list, or a hard drive somewhere in the J. Edgar Hoover building in Washington, D.C.  Aren’t you?

1) When I saw that the recent resignation by CIA director David Petraeus was being handled by the FBI, my suspicions were confirmed as to who really had the greatest clout among the myriad clandestine governmental spy agencies.

2) I also knew that following 9-11, the unanimous passing of the Patriot Act gave the ACLU fits, because  it allowed even more latitude for the “feds” to seek information through the phone and internet systems of communications.

3) Finally, I was aware that despite predictions of its demise, ISDN is a legacy technology entrenched in the DNA of voice-over work and is not about to go away, despite the increasing difficulty to have it installed and serviced in some parts of the country.

Put 1, 2, and 3 above together, and you have the perfect paranoia explaining the basis of an article recently published by SoftwareStudies.org.  Titiled “Tapping into ISDN“, the well-written essay explains the growing frustration on the part of FBI operatives with ISDN.  To wit:  “…the bureau claims to lack the present capability to intercept ISDN…”

This could actually present a new revenue source for ISDN voice talent.  We could start advertising our “surveillance free communications capability” and begin charging for private, personal phone time in our booths.  :)

Seriously, the article is a quick, interesting read.

CourVO

SoundStreak – From the Top

Throw away most of your previous concepts of remote session recordings for this blog article.

This will be a detailed, inside tour of SoundStreak, as told by its CEO, Dan Caligor…and he admits, “…it takes people a while to Grok this.”

Most of you know of my interest in technological advances prompting changes in our VO business paradigms.  I’ve blogged about “7 Disruptive Technologies That Have Shaped the Business of VoiceOvers“, and other product and device reviews.

Yet, one bastion of seemingly unchanging technology is the ISDN session.  Source-Connect has tried, but (in my estimation) fallen short in mounting a serious challenge to ISDN…largely by failing to make the case with influential studios (see also my recent blog on ConnectionOpen).

ADVANCING THE MODEL

Now, SoundStreak is about to break on the scene with an approach that may indeed replace ISDN for ease, quality, and reliability of use.  They’ll likely do it by sidestepping the entire infrastructure behind the TelCo-based (and old) technology of ISDN…and it’s much more, actually than ISDN ever offered.  It’s a system…a collaboration.  As Dan told me: “It’s a service, not a product”.

At it’s heart, SoundStreak makes use of the internet — but not at all in the way you might expect — to achieve it’s high-quality and reliability sessions.

DAN CALIGOR

First of all…let me tell you, I spent more than an hour with CEO Dan Caligor on a Skype call two days ago. No subject was off-the-table.  He led me on a sample session, and openly answered all my questions.  Aside from being a graduate of NYU’s film school, Dan morphed into an advisor to early-stage companies.  He began to work with a man who had developed the idea for SoundStreak as a sort of academic exercise, and eventually became a partner in the start-up company that resulted.  The initial vision for SoundStreak was for implementation in on-air network studios, with the implicit promise of simplicity and ease-of-use.

That original play for SoundStreak ran out of money, but now is back, stronger, broader, deeper, and more ready for prime-time than ever.

Dan himself has grown from a self-described start-up business advisor to an engineer-level technology geek fully fluent in all the idiosyncrasies of our VO corner of the Universe.  He clearly has done his homework on the marketplace, the challenges of our business, and need for a convenient long-distance recording system fair to both parties.

WHAT SOUNDSTREAK IS NOT

  • A costly, complicated hardware system
  • Proprietary software
  • Hard to install
  • Confusing to operate
  • A casting system (yet)
  • A barrier between client and talent

SOUNDSTREAK, THE PROGRAM

Caligor stated to me:  “…we are a capture and collaboration tool offered as a service, rather than as a product…”  (remember:  you must Grok)

Right now SoundStreak is in “private Beta”, which means you have to request an invitation or be invited by a current Beta member (there’s a few hundred right now).  Currently, it’s available as a free download and will install  on Mac OSX 10.6, a.k.a Snow Leopard or later.  Caligor says they’re getting as many requests for older Apple OS support as they are for MS Windows support.  He also says they honor anyone who requests an invite, it’s just a matter of working through the backlog.

The software must be installed on both the talent and the production (the person hiring talent) side.  It’s the  same application.  Once installed and signed on, both parties can see each other.  You are not directly connected to the other party…EVERYTHING runs through the SoundStreak servers (more on why this is important, later).

THE SESSION STEP BY STEP

  • The producer begins the session by choosing a name for the session, and sends you what Caligor calls the “backing assets”.  That could be a video you need to match in your narration…the script… or any other materials you need to perform your voice work for the client.
  • The producer can update those materials…change, add, edit, or otherwise augment them during the session, and the changes immediately take place on both ends. SoundStreak is designed so that the talent and the production side always see and hear the same thing.

    {click to enlarge}

  • It’s important to note that those assets are not “streaming”.  After sending the materials, they reside on your computer till the session ends…so there’s never any latency when matching, say, voice to video.  For security reasons, those “assets” get deleted from the production and talent computers at the end of every session…but the recording you’re about to do does not get deleted from your home computer.
  • You can open multiple scripts and videos.  The system keeps track of which asset you use, so when you play it back, it plays in sync with the backing asset on both ends of the session.
  • Recording is done in .wav, aiff, and broadcast .wav, so you can pass-through time-coding.  You can pick audio resolution all the way up to 96k, 24-bit, but the system resolves to 41.1k, 16-bit.
  • The producer, then, after loading the backing asset, presses “record”.  The system counts you in: 3-2-1, and you’ll read to the copy. You’ll hear it in your headphones as you read, and when you’re through, the producers presses “stop”. During the actual take, the producer listens to you over VOIP.  There is a little bit of latency, according to the broadband pipe.
  • Also, as soon as as soon as the in-session light goes on,  a voice patch is activated, so that the production person and the talent person are talking through the system.  It’s a built-in voice-patch..and it’s a smart phone patch, muting in the right order,with a talk-back button.  Voice patch works between takes and from the first moment of the session to the last.  When you’re not recording, it’s unmuted, but can manually over-ridden.

    {click to enlarge}

  • At the bottom of the screen, there’s a take sheet list.  There, the producer controls playback of different takes. As you do takes, each one is appended to this list as a file.
  • Caligor explains: “…the whole principal of SoundStreak is that all the assets are always playing locally — both the takes, and the backing assets, and the playback is actually being synchronized through very low-bandwidth signals  so it’s always optimized to work with the smallest possible amount of bandwidth…”  Caligor says most of the available bandwidth is used to facilitate the voice-patch.
  • There is never any compression of any soundfiles at any time during any session.
  • After recording is stopped a review copy of the of the take — down-rezzed so it will transfer quickly — is sent to the Production machine within seconds.  Hopefully at some point during the session (arbitrarily set by SoundStreak at 90-mins), the producer hears what he/she likes and chooses a “buy take”.  Selecting that, automatically downloads the hi-res recording of that take from the talent computer — through the SoundStreak servers — to the producer’s computer.  The “buy take” is uncompressed.  It might take 3 to 30 seconds to download, depending on how big file is, the resolution of the file, and the fatness of the pipe connecting talent to the server to the producer.
  • All during this time, all the talent has had to do is set the mic level, accept the invitation, and perform.  This could seriously change the way Voice Actors record on-the-road!
  • Both sides of the exchange have local copies of the takes.  The talent has a hi-res and lo-res of every take (local on their machine), but not the backing assets. The producer only gets the buy-takes…and remember the backing assets are deleted at the end of the session.

    {click to enlarge}

  • As soon as the session is over, both parties immediately receive an automatic email reporting most all aspects of the session: who’s the talent, who’s the producer, the file format, # of takes you did, start times, stop times…which take was the buy-take and more.  The Session Summary email includes direct links to the archived version of each buy take on the server, so anyone you send the email to can download it directly to their machine.
  • Done!

PRICING

SoundStreak is free right now, and probably will be for some time.  Caligor says: “…the reason we’re going to keep it free for a while, is that we understand this is people’s livelihood, and as important as we think our tool is, it’s really just a screwdriver in their box, and it’s not fair to ask people to bet their livelihood on something, let alone charge them to bet their livelihood on something until they’re really comfortable with it, and therefore, we want to make that comfort level really possible easy to achieve.”

Eventually Caligor envisions a token-system of accounting.  Right now, everyone gets 10 tokens, and when it gets down to one or two, you get ten more free tokens.  Their plan is that most sessions, though, would be paid by the producer, in keeping with a similar protocol usually enjoyed by talent during ISDN sessions, where the producer pays for the long-distance call.  One token — from either party — pays for one session, again, set as 90-minutes or less.

SOUNDSTREAK’S SERVER

That every session is commissioned through SoundStreak’s servers is a plus.  Caligor says: “… it allows a lot of archiving and safety and control, and for enterprise customers, it allows people to traverse corporate firewalls. That’s a huge issue at big operations. The guys in IT love us. Instead of opening up new connections in foreign places, which makes IT alarms go off…this is a single IP address…so you’re always talking to the server, not each other…”

Caligor says the entire system from top to bottom, including the server integrity is 99% bullet-proof.  They’re about to end the “private Beta”, and go into a “free trial version”.  They’ve never been able to crash the server, even during multiple sessions.  Caligor says they run across a rare instance or two where the talent’s audio equipment presents a software driver they haven’t seen yet, but nothing that’s stopped the session.  He stressed a number of times during our interview how much they’ve spent in time and engineering to make the product robust.

TESTING AND SUPPORT

The operation is lean…about 6 staffers.  They subcontract out some of the development, and most everyone is taking calls and answering emails.  With wider acceptance and use, Caligor anticipates more staff to handle customer support.

They want lots and lots of users to test the system.  Right now, the majority of users are talent.  Caligor encourages talent to tell their favorite studios about the product, and engage in tests with THEM.  This is key, and may be SoundStreak’s biggest challenge: getting talent, but especially Studios and producers to figure out how to make it work for their business, and get comfortable that it’s not some kind of threat to them.

SoundStreak does require a bit of a mind-shift to understand how it differs from what’s now comfortable.  We’re all busy, and we may not have the time to consider changing to, or buying into an entire new paradigm.  A chicken-or-the-egg syndrome sets in.  Talent won’t work with it until the studios require it, and studios won’t require it until they know talent are comfortable with it.

Caligor is confident SoundStreak is a solid product that will win over converts.  “I would rather have lots of users soon, than a little or a lot of revenue soon. I’m confident that once people try it out, they’ll see its potential.”

CourVO

ConnectionOpen

Even though it’s been in beta since somewhere back  at the end of the last decade, SoundStreak is enjoying a resurgence.  Mentions of voice artists testing the product are showing up on plenty of online forums.  I blogged about SoundStreak on Feb 13th, excited about the possibilities, only to find it’s strictly made for Macs.

Nonetheless, I’ve just rec’d the go-ahead to do a recorded interview with the CEO, Dan Caligor…which we’re trying to schedule.

In the meantime, up pops ConnectionOpen.com!  I picked it up in a post from voice talent Randy Morrison in the VAU Facebook group, and it promptly garnered 60+ responses that were all over the map…including issues with browser versions, JAVA installs, and bandwidth minimums (minimum 3 Mbps down/512 Kbps up).  It is apparently compatible with Mac and Windows, though…and Randy appears to be involved with the company (randymorrison@breakalip.com).

The site claims that with ConnectionOpen you “…experience virtually lagless/lossless communication for a fraction of the cost of ISDN. Create a “studio environment” wherever you are 24/7 using your computer and broadband. Easy to set up, easy to use. A few clicks… and you’re already there…”

I’m all for these alternatives to ISDN, which I see as dying a slow death despite the protestations of established studios and voice actors.  They’re mostly on the East and West Coasts, and in THOSE locations, ISDN is strong.  But everywhere else, installation, costs, and connections are issues. The major Telcos are dropping infrastructure and support.  Source-Connect is there, but it’s never seemed to have caught on.

So give ConnectionOpen a look…just be ready to have to tinker with it, and maybe use tech support to make it fly.  While Randy Morrison and Co., seem to be very responsive to dealing with the glitches…it may not be a turnkey solution…yet.

CourVO

ISDN R.I.P…?

Read into the archives of this blog, and you’ll see a long and bloody history of my wrestling match with the ISDN demons.  More often than not, I found myself pinned with my shoulders to the mat.

Once you raise the question about ISDN’s possible demise, you inevitably hear from a usually seasoned old-guard of voice-actors that “…ISDN has always been there, and it ain’t goin’ away any time soon!…”  That may be, but indicators show a growing inveitability that the major TelCos are withdrawing their infrastructure support for ISDN.  Bottom line:  It just isn’t financially worthwhile for them.

To see a much deeper discussion of this, read George Whittam’s blog:  ISDN USERS: IT’S TIME TO GET A BACKUP SYSTEM.

George is not the only one saying this, but George is the only one saying it with the substantial gravity of his knowledge and experience.  To that end, you may want to put a new date on your calendar:  November 29th, 6pm PST.  George and VoiceOverXtra’s John Florian are teaming up for a seminar that night on ISDN & Alternatives.  This will be a worthwhile session.

I’m already into Source Connect…and have been for 4 years.  My handle is (big surprise) COURVO.  Connect with me on the Source-Elements site if you want to. I’m happy to help anyone with a test ISDN or SC session.  My ISDN #’s are 702-240-2107, -2157

(author’s note 11-25-11.  Make a point to read Beau Weaver’s comments below in addendum to this blog article.  His experience speaks volumes, and he fleshes out a lot of answers to these issues.)

CourVO

Hospice for ISDN

Ancient relic, or diehard survivor?

ISDN continues to surprise all those who predicted it’s death years ago…a hold-over from a bygone era that is as entrenched as horseshoe crabs are old.

With blazing fast developments on the digital scene…how long can ISDN hold out?  Read on:

[Read more...]

ISDN’s Gradual Demise?

John McClain: owner, President, CEO, and all around Grand Poobah of Dog and Pony Studios in Las Vegas is my ISDN conscience.  Somewhere along the line he’s taken to advising me when he gets a tidbit about not-so-subtle hernias appearing in the soft underbelly of ISDN service in America.

Lately, it seems to be taking the form of Telcos silently strangling this mainstay of audio connections by cutting back on the long-distance connections that make it all work. Let’s face it…the AT&T’s of the world LOSE money on ISDN.  This service is entrenched in the best VO studios across the country, so a quick demise is not likely, but a slow death by attrition is possible.

Follow this link to a thread on the Gearslutz Post Production forum revealing the latest woes:

http://www.gearslutz.com/board/post-production-forum/601335-wow-where-get-long-distance-international-service-isdn.html

CourVO

ISDN Dropped

On my Voice-Over Friends Group on FaceBook, Arlene Cooke points to a NY Times article discussing a list of certain words that are being cycled OUT of the Times’ style book, and apparently the acronym ISDN (Integrated Services Digital Network) is one of them.

‘Just another reason never to read the NYT in my book.

But in case you’d like to see their reasoning, you can read The Latest in Style by Philip Corbett here.

BTW, ISDN never caught-on here as it has in Europe, where it’s still a mainstay in most systems.  For more about ISDN, read any of the many articles in this blog on the subject, by enterng the search string ISDN in the dialogue box at the top right of this page.

CourVO